Sunday, February 9, 2014

"Son of God" movie


Many of us have probably seen previews for or heard news about the upcoming film "Son of God," due to release Feb. 28. As the title clearly implies, it is a movie chronicling the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus. The movie employs scenes from "The Bible" miniseries that aired last year and will include deleted and additional footage. If you haven't heard anything about the film, check out one of the trailers below:
 
Thinking about this release reminded me of a project I did my senior year of college. In this project I explored the interplay between the biblical Gospels, "Jesus films," and culture. My underlying thesis was that any film, TV show, etc. depicting Jesus better reflects the producing culture than it does the actual, historical Jesus. For the project I studied the films The Greatest Story Ever Told (1965) and Jesus (TV movie, 2000). 

What I concluded by the end was that each film clearly reflects the cultural times, trends, and tendencies of its era. For example, the Jesus of Greatest Story is a Jesus for the 1960's. This Jesus is stoic and removed from earthly life (a "heavenly" being if you will); the type of Jesus "needed" to combat the revolutionary movements of the 60's. This film's Jesus is also depicted as a hero in the style of an American Western, a popular film genre of the era. Meanwhile, Jesus offers a more "modern" Jesus fitting with the culture of the early 2000's. This new and improved Jesus is an "earthy" Jesus trying to discover his identity. He even briefly considers a romantic relationship. If it weren't for the ancient garb, 2000's Jesus could easily be mistaken for any young millennial searching for their identity and meaning in a complex world.
 
Now that we face a new Jesus film, I am fascinated by what kind of Jesus will be depicted and how he will reflect our culture in 2014. When the film comes out I hope to analyze it for myself, but first I'd like to explain how I went about studying each Jesus film so you can join me in better understanding our cultural Jesuses from the Jesus presented in our Scriptures.

To study each film, I applied a method of biblical interpretation called "redaction criticism." This method compares biblical texts with their source materials and notes how the author "redacts," or changes, the original text. Changes might include additions, deletions, or word and stylistic alterations. For example, it is commonly assumed that Mark was the first Gospel written and that Matthew and Luke both used material from Mark as well as from other sources in compiling their gospels. We can compare the passages in Matthew or Luke that clearly borrow from Mark and observe how Matthew/Luke make changes. From there we develop theories on possible theological or artistic motivations for making those changes.

For instance, compare Matt. 16:13-23 and Mark 8:27-33. Both stories are almost identical (even word for word) with the exception of a few places where Matthew changes the story. Two changes stand out. First, whereas Mark 8:33 says that Jesus "rebuked" Peter (same word for rebuking demons), Matthew 16:23 changes "rebuke" to the weaker verb "said." It's just a statement, not a rebuke of a demon. Second, Matthew adds an entire section of praise for Peter from Jesus in 16:17-19. In Mark's version, Peter says "You are the Messiah" and immediately gets "rebuked" (the first of 2 times). In Matthew, Peter receives praise from Jesus and only gets "told" off later when he tries to convince Jesus not to die.

Biblical scholars note these changes (along with many similar changes in Matthew's Gospel) and conclude that Matthew tends to portray the disciples as constantly improving in their faith. Meanwhile, Mark holds a negative view of the disciples, observing their faith shrinking and increasing thickness with each chapter. The reason for this is because Matthew and Mark are emphasizing different aspects of discipleship to best convey different messages for different audiences.

I suggest we can treat Jesus films as a "cultural text" and apply the same method. In the case of such films, we know the primary source material--the biblical Gospels. However, no film uses the Gospels as its only source. Jesus films also borrow from pop culture, Christian (and cultural) tradition, and the director's imagination/experience. Even films with dialogue taken only from the Gospels (such as The Gospel of John) still use other sources in what they visually depict on screen.

So, as we watch any Jesus film, we need to note what is borrowed from the biblical Gospels, what is added to the Gospel narratives, and what is left out. These places in the dialogue and plot that differ from the biblical narratives are crucial for understanding the cultural Jesus being presented in the movie. When we note these changes, we need to ask, "Why present Jesus in that manner? Why make that change?" Even noting camera angles and music can tell us about what kind of Jesus we are seeing on screen.

I'll explain more of how this can work in my next post and will maybe even throw out of few ideas based on the trailer. Until then, let me know what you think about approaching Jesus films in this way.

Wednesday, January 29, 2014

Make me a Rhoda

Yes, it's been a long time since I've written a real post (although I'm sure not many people noticed with such a long hiatus), but maybe I'll be able to make this a better habit.

As I was preparing for my Wednesday night youth lesson I suddenly became really convicted by the story I was studying [SPOILER ALERT: If you're one of my students you'll hear this again tomorrow night.] I guess even us pastors need our toes stepped on from time to time (everyday would probably be best).

Our youth group is currently studying through the book of Acts, and this week we are on Acts 12. This is the chapter where Peter is miraculously released from prison by an angel, only to be left stranded outside a house by an overexcited servant girl named Rhoda.

Luke tells us the Christians gathered in the house had been "praying." Almost certainly one of their top prayer concerns was Peter, one of the great leaders of the church who had just been arrested. So, it's strange that no one believes Rhoda when she tells them Peter is standing outside. They had been praying for God to help Peter. It seems odd to me...

But not that odd. As I think about it, that is what my prayer life looks like. I wonder if that house full of Jesus followers really believed that God would hear their prayers and take action. Perhaps they were just like me. All too often my prayers are rushed and shallow. Too many times I pray with that nasty little voice in my head whispering that my prayers are pointless. I throw empty words into the empty void between me and a far-off God and know that he won't do anything.

But then there is Rhoda, a simple servant girl. Whether she was praying herself or simply listening to the prayers of the house, she had her eyes (and ears) open to readily see what God was doing in response to those prayers. She didn't know what was coming, but she was ready. She recognized God's handiwork immediately.

Rhoda reminds me of the truth I easily forget--God is not distant, nor is He idle. When I pray, or sing, or, or work, I do so in the very presence of God. And as I speak, He hears me. And not only does He respond and take action, but He is already in action, moving through the halls of my house and the streets of my city. He may not answer in the way I want, but I must keep my eyes wide open and my ears ready because He will answer, and it will probably be with something better than I could have imagined. The question I must face is whether I will pray and live in anticipation that God will (and is) acting, or if I will blindly walk through life ignorant of the creating, sustaining Love that surrounds me. Make me a Rhoda.

Tuesday, November 12, 2013

How to Hold a Hand

Hey everyone,

Sorry it's been a long time since I've posted on my blog. I've been really busy the past two years with finishing grad school. Hopefully I will get some new posts up soon now that I am done with school.

I'm writing right now to let you know that I recently published one of my short stories on Amazon. You can get it for Kindle here or at http://www.amazon.com/dp/B00GM5MECY . The story is called "How to Hold a Hand." It is about two families--one in America and one in war-torn Palestine. For a limited time (Nov. 13-15, 2013) you can get it for free. Hope you enjoy it!

Saturday, May 21, 2011

What to Do When the World is Ending

Well, it's May 21, but I haven't heard any reports of earthquakes in Asia yet. So, I figured doing a blog post wouldn't be a waste of my final hours. However, all this talk about the end of the world does spark a good question: If you knew the world was going to end tomorrow how would you spend that time?

An article in TIME this week invited readers to answer that question. Here are some of the answers they provided:


-I would go to a really fancy museum and touch everything
-I'd buy the most expensive bottle of scotch I could get my hands on (like $1,000) and drink it. Oh, and I'd buy a cigar to go with it
-Feel the emotions of exposing myself on public transportation
-Punch my boss
-Finally tell all those kids with the saggy pants to pull their pants up
-Bust dogs out of the shelter and gorillas out of the zoo
-Eat pies and cheese and stuff

-I'd have my girlfriend come over and just lay in bed with me wearing our finest formalwear like the elderly couple in Titanic
-Buy expensive crystal wine glasses and smash them against a wall
-I'd probably just start asking random really hot girls if they want to sleep with me
-Well, I'd definitely stop folding laundry
-Eat nothing but $2 Taco Bell meals
-Watch Party of Five on Netflix
-Challenge Michael Jordan to a one on one

It was interesting to me that most of the answers provided involved either splurging on one's self or carrying out those secret mischievous (or sinful) acts we've always wanted to do. I found this a fascinating contrast to the answer that Martin Luther provided so long ago. When contemplating what he would do if he knew the world was going to end he said that he would plant a tree. What a difference.
Perhaps the difference lies in our belief in the end. If we believe that the end of the world is  the ultimate end or if we believe that there is only heaven to look forward to, then such earthly desires for those final hours make sense. After all, you won't have another chance.

However, if we believe in the Christian hope of resurrection then what we do on this earth does matter. Our work is not in vain. When Christ does come it won't be as the destroyer of worlds but as the one who comes to redeem, resurrect, and recreate what has been lost.

Monday, December 6, 2010

Power and History

In discussions over the so-called Deuteronomic History, many recent scholars have put forth arguments claiming that the entire history of Israel was constructed at a time during the later monarchy in the southern kingdom (perhaps by Hezekiah or Josiah). Therefore, all of this history is filtered through the lens of a 6th-8th century Judean perspective. In these theories, the last one standing got to write and edit history. However, even if we point out weaknesses in this reductionistic approach to OT history, we cannot escape the fact that someone authored and edited these works commonly known as "histories."

Furthermore, in the ancient world, "history" was not seen as something to be "objective." Rather, one told "history" through one's unique lens and theology. There was no problem with mixing theological biases and historical claims.

However, as we think about today, we are really not all that different. We all filter our own history through our particular biases and beliefs. For example, our position as American citizens will naturally color how we approach history that involves the United States. Similarly, for those who are Christians, we will probably approach church history in a different manner than non-Christians.

Finally, even if we do not accept reductionistic claims about Israel's history-writing, we can at least accept their argument that the one with power, or the last one standing, has a significant impact on how the story is told. With that in mind, we need to be aware of ways in which we stand in positions of power. If it is true that such positions also carry with them the ability to shape the story of history, then we must act with great care and responsibility to ensure that our biases do not color our take on history in a way that is unrealistic or even harmful.

Friday, December 3, 2010

Jehoiachin in Babylon

The OT books of history end on a dark note. The northern kingdom falls in 2 Kings 17 after generations of sin. Then, the southern kingdom and Jerusalem also fall in the final chapter of 2 Kings (2 Kgs. 25). The fall of Jerusalem is an especially tragic event. King Zedekiah is captured, forced to watch the deaths of his sons, and then is blinded by the Babylonians (25:6-7). Then, the Temple is burned along with "every important building" (25:9). Finally, the holy objects of the Temple and the people of Jerusalem are carried off to Babylon.

Thus, the historical books end with chaos, darkness, and despair. All that Israel had worked for since the Exodus seems to have been undone. The land is lost, the Temple is lost, and the people are lost. However, there is perhaps a glimmer of hope at the very end.

2 Kings 25:27-30, the final verses of the book, tell the brief story of King Jehoiachin, who had been captured by the Babylonians prior to the destruction of Jerusalem. The author tells the reader that the Jehoiachin was released from prison and was even given a seat of honor at the king's table. Although this is only a small glimpse of hope, it is at least a sign that Judah has not been completely destroyed and abandoned by God.

This rhetorical move is reminiscent of the final scene of the movie "The Road." This movie tells the tale of a father and son who attempt to live and travel in a post-apocalyptic world with no sunshine that is also infested with cannibals. Although the father dies in the end, leaving the boy alone in this god-forsaken world, there is also a tiny ray of hope at the end. The boy has the good fortune of meeting up with another small family who are willing to take him in and show him kindness. Although the movie ends here and does not offer hope for the improvement of the world nor give assurances that this family will survive, there is at least a small sense of hope at the end. This short story in 2 Kings works similarly. Although there is no guarantee that Israel will make a glorious return, there is hope held up that perhaps not all is lost.